NO GRAVE LEFT UN-ROBBED

Grave robbing was added to this family’s list of crimes: The grave robber, the grandson of the murderer, was not yet born when Stott, Scott and Wilson were hung, August 11, 1888. A co-conspirator of the murders, the son-in-law of the killer -- married to the killer’s daughter -- was present during the facilitation process and subsequent murders of James Warren Stott, James Lane Scott and William Jefferson Wilson. The son-in-law was the same age as Stott -- born in 1863 -- and was one of the “riders from the north.” The killer’s daughter and her husband lived in Day Wash, three miles north of Jamie Stott’s Aztec Spring Ranch in Apache County, Arizona Territory (AZT). 

Jamie Stott was soon to receive his Homestead Deed for the quarter section (160 acres) after he “proved up” on it during his three-year required occupancy — but first, Jamie was mandated to publicly file his intention in the Capitol in Prescott. This caused him to sign his own death warrant. It expedited the urgency to take his ranches by killing him — the Aztec Land and Cattle Company (Hashknife outfit) had to be taught a lesson.

Five miles north of Jamie’s Aztec Spring Ranch lived one of the killer’s sons — also a co-conspirator of the murder of the three boys. He resided in Decker Wash. Geographically, the two washes are parallel to each other and approximately two miles apart. This ranch was where the “riders from the north” assembled and spent the night of august 10, 1888. The next day duplicated the same date as the Dead Man’s hand, held by Bill Hickok during his last poker game in Deadwood, South Dakota. He was holding aces and eights — 8-11-88 -- (this murder was never solved.) However, I can name all of the “riders from the north” at a later date with 99% accuracy. I will also name the “word of mouth beguile riders.” These fast riders delivered oral messages back and forth (approximately five miles apart) from the two ranches — 20 minutes each way by horse. The oral messages were essential in the orchestration of the hangings that were to take place at the Aztec Spring Ranch. There were two eyewitnesses.

Bear Springs Ranch was a sister ranch of Jamie Stott’s and was located two miles southwest of the Aztec Spring Ranch. The good grass and water would serve the 20+ murderers and their horses at that location. These murderers came from the Pleasant Valley and Globe areas. They had James Lane Scott, III in tow as they came up over the Mogollon Rim on August 10, 1888. Eyewitness testimony claimed there were 28 men. The Apache County Deputy Sheriff, Dennis Houck, claimed 40 masked men took his prisoners away and that he didn’t know what happened after that. For the past 131 years, this story has prevailed and no one has ever questioned it — until now — I know the truth.

The total weight of men and horses would tally up to about 30-40-thousand pounds of mass. Apache County Sheriff, Commodore Perry Owens was leading. This discovery was the key to solving 99% of these murders.

In Earl Forest’s book, titled Arizona’s Dark and Bloody Ground, he describes the chilling events of the grave robbing process. .Stott’s gold ring was last seen in July, 1942 with his skeletal remains. It was said that the ring was taken and re-sized for the killer’s grandson’s ranch foreman’s wife-to -be. He was 47 years old at the time of the exhuming process. Jamie was placed in another grave at a considerable distance from his two comrades. More than one schadenfreude took great pleasure in committing these robberies of the grave — this horrific crime.

After all these years of helping me solve these murders, Dawn Wilson Investigative Services has been helping me -- on a moment’s notice -- to get accurate chronological evidence -- dates, timing, perpetrators and more. She has never failed these victims while seeking “the truth.”
Ending old patterns
By Joan Courtney March 20, 2026
Ending old patterns
Carving wood spirts from Cottonwood
By Anne Groebner March 20, 2026
Carving wood spirts from Cottonwood
Tonto Natural Bridge
By Annemarie Eveland March 20, 2026
Tonto Natural Bridge
Taking on more challenging activities
By Rob Bettaso March 20, 2026
Taking on more challenging activities
Visualize your cycling adventures
By Carol Godwin March 20, 2026
Visualize your cycling adventures
Writer, artist and long time resident of the White Mountains
By Anne Groebner March 20, 2026
Writer, artist and long time resident of the White Mountains
Horseback riding the White Mountain Trail System, Arizona
By Allanna Jackson March 20, 2026
Horseback riding the White Mountain Trail System, Arizona
Birding Opportunities in the White Mountains of Arizona
By Dan Groebner March 20, 2026
Birding Opportunities in the White Mountains of Arizona
The personification of a tree can breathe life into what is too easily disregarded as an inanimate o
By Erik Alcumbrac March 19, 2026
The personification of a tree can breathe life into what is too easily disregarded as an inanimate object
The “Great Bird Depression of 2025-26” in the White Mountains.
By Ruth Anne Groebner February 26, 2026
The “Great Bird Depression of 2025-26” in the White Mountains.
More Posts